Finding the perfect holster for your Glock 17 is about more than just convenience; it’s a critical decision that impacts your safety, comfort, and readiness. The right holster should securely retain your firearm while allowing for a smooth, consistent draw, whether you’re on the range or carrying for personal defense. With countless options on the market, from minimalist Kydex to classic leather, the choice can be overwhelming.
To simplify your search, we put a wide array of holsters through their paces in real-world range testing. This roundup focuses on performance, durability, and practical features, highlighting ten of the best holsters for the Glock 17 available in 2025. Our goal is to provide you with the information needed to select a holster that you can trust and rely on every day.
Our Top Picks for Glock 17 Holsters
- Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster
- CYA Supply Co. Base IWB Concealed Carry Holster
- CYTAC OWB Holster for Glock 17 22 31
- Comp-Tac International Holster
- 1791 GUNLEATHER XDS Thumb Break Holster
- Made in USA Suede Leather IWB Holster
- EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER Pistol Universal Holster
- Vedder Holsters LightTuck IWB Kydex Gun Holster
- BLACKHAWK Serpa CQC Concealment Holster
- Tier 1 Concealed Axis Elite Holster for Glock 17
Relentless Tactical The Defender Leather IWB Holster
For those who appreciate the classic feel and breaking-in process of a quality leather holster, the Relentless Tactical Defender is a top-tier choice. Crafted in the USA, this inside-the-waistband holster offers a comfortable and secure carry method that molds to your body over time. Its exceptional versatility is a major benefit, as it is designed to fit a vast array of popular handguns beyond the Glock 17, including various Glock models, Smith & Wesson Shields, and Taurus pistols.
The holster’s design prioritizes a smooth draw and reliable retention, with a reinforced mouth that prevents collapsing when re-holstering. Made from durable saddle leather, it is built to last and develops a unique patina with use. This is an ideal option for anyone seeking a single, high-quality leather holster that can accommodate multiple firearms in their collection.
CYA Supply Co. Base IWB Concealed Carry Holster
The CYA Supply Co. Base Holster provides a no-fuss, highly functional Kydex option for everyday concealed carry. As a veteran-owned company manufacturing in the USA, CYA focuses on precision and reliability. This holster is specifically molded for the Glock 17 Gen 3-5, ensuring a precise and secure fit that minimizes wobble and provides excellent trigger guard coverage.
Key features include easily adjustable retention and cant, allowing you to customize the draw angle and how tightly the holster grips your pistol. Constructed from .08″ thick Boltaron, it is both durable and lightweight. The strong, wide belt clip offers a solid anchor on your belt, making this holster a practical and affordable workhorse for daily use.
CYTAC OWB Holster for Glock 17 22 31
If you need a secure and accessible outside-the-waistband holster for range duty or open carry, the CYTAC model is a strong contender. It features a Level II retention system that automatically locks onto your pistol’s trigger guard, confirmed by an audible “click” for peace of mind. The release is intuitive, using your index finger to press a prominently placed button for a quick draw.
Made from tough military polymer, this holster is built to withstand rigorous use and is easy to maintain. The open-bottom design accommodates longer barrels and threaded barrels, adding to its versatility. With an adjustable cant and a lightweight profile, it offers a balance of security and convenience for active shooting scenarios.
Comp-Tac International Holster
The Comp-Tac International is a competition-ready OWB holster that brings a high level of customization to the shooter. Constructed entirely from Kydex, it provides a rigid, consistent draw and excellent durability. This holster is engineered for speed and stability, making it a favorite among action shooting sports enthusiasts who use their Glock 17.
What sets the International apart is its incredible versatility in mounting. It comes with three mounting options: a belt mount, a paddle mount, and a drop offset piece. With 16 possible mounting variations and adjustable cant, you can fine-tune the holster’s position to match your exact body mechanics and competition style for optimal performance.
1791 GUNLEATHER XDS Thumb Break Holster
1791 Gunleather combines traditional craftsmanship with modern design in their XDS Thumb Break Holster. Made from 100% American steerhide, this OWB holster offers a classic look without sacrificing security. The thumb break strap provides an additional layer of retention, which can be particularly reassuring during physical activity.
This holster is designed for versatility, accommodating a wide range of popular handguns, including the Glock 17. It also allows for multi-cant positioning, so you can wear it in a straight drop, FBI cant, or anywhere in between. The reinforced construction and double stitching ensure this is a holster that will provide years of reliable service with a timeless aesthetic.
Made in USA Suede Leather IWB Holster
This suede leather IWB holster prioritizes comfort for all-day concealed carry. The soft suede interior is gentle against your skin and helps keep the holster in place by gripping your clothing. Like its Relentless Tactical counterpart, it boasts impressive versatility, fitting a long list of full-size and compact pistols in 9mm, .40, and .45 calibers.
Its minimalist design reduces bulk, making it easier to conceal your Glock 17 without printing. The suede material is flexible and forms to your body, increasing comfort over extended periods. This is an excellent option for those who value a soft, comfortable feel against their skin and need a holster that can serve multiple firearms.
EXCELLENT ELITE SPANKER Pistol Universal Adjustable Holster
For a budget-friendly and highly adaptable option, the Excellent Elite Spanker universal holster is worth considering. Constructed from durable 500D Cordura Nylon, this holster is built to handle rough use. Its universal design is intended to fit a wide range of pistols, including the Glock 17, M1911, and many others.
The large inner space and adjustable magic sticker (hook-and-loop closure) allow it to accommodate pistols with attached flashlights or lasers. It is also MOLLE-compatible, making it a practical choice for tactical vests or range bags. This holster is best suited for range use or tactical applications where absolute precision of fit is less critical than overall versatility and attachment options.
Vedder Holsters LightTuck IWB Kydex Holster
The Vedder LightTuck is a fan-favorite in the concealed carry community, known for its exceptional quality and customization. This Kydex IWB holster is precisely molded for the Glock 17, offering a perfect snap-fit retention that is both secure and easily adjustable with an included Allen wrench. The holster’s slim profile makes it one of the most concealable options available.
A standout feature is the patented Vedder ClipTuck belt clip, which is extra-wide for stability and can be tuckable for maximum concealment with an untucked shirt. The holster also offers a full range of adjustable cant, allowing you to carry from straight up to a significant forward tilt. The comfort-rounded edges ensure it won’t dig into your skin during all-day wear.
BLACKHAWK Serpa CQC Concealment Holster
The BLACKHAWK Serpa CQC is a legendary OWB holster known for its unique and highly effective retention system. The SERPA Auto-Lock system uses a trigger finger-release mechanism that reinforces proper draw technique by guiding your finger into a safe, high position along the holster as you draw. This system provides a high level of security without sacrificing speed.
Constructed from a durable polymer, the holster is built to last and performs reliably in various conditions. An audible click confirms when the pistol is securely locked in place. While its use requires dedicated training to master the muscle memory, the Serpa remains a popular choice for those who prioritize a secure, active retention system for their Glock 17.
Tier 1 Concealed Axis Elite Holster for Glock 17
The Tier 1 Concealed Axis Elite represents the pinnacle of appendix carry (AIWB) holster design. This modular system is more than just a holster; it’s an integrated platform that includes a holster for your Glock 17 and a connected magazine carrier. The two pieces are joined by a flexible, elastic cord that allows them to move independently, conforming to your body’s movements for superior comfort and concealment.
Made from premium materials with exacting laser-cut specifications, the Axis Elite offers a precise fit, adjustable retention, and multiple ride height options. It is engineered to promote a smooth draw and comfortable all-day carry, even while sitting or driving. For the serious concealed carrier who prefers appendix carry, the Axis Elite is a top-shelf solution that balances high performance with everyday comfort.
Buying Guide: How to Choose the Best Holster for Your Glock 17
After spending a lot of time at the range testing different options for the Glock 17, I have learned that a holster is not just an accessory; it is a critical piece of gear. Your choice directly impacts your safety, draw speed, and overall comfort. Whether you are looking for a holster for concealed carry, competition, or duty use, there are a few key factors you need to consider before making a purchase.
First, decide on the carry position. Inside the Waistband (IWB) holsters are popular for concealed carry, tucking the pistol securely against your body. Outside the Waistband (OWB) holsters are often used for range work, competition, or duty carry, as they are generally more comfortable and allow for a faster draw. Your lifestyle and typical clothing will largely dictate which style is best for you.
Next, look at the material. Kydex is a modern thermoplastic that is my personal favorite for its rigid retention and excellent click feedback when the pistol is seated. It is also lightweight and highly durable. Leather holsters offer a classic look and can be very comfortable, but they can break down over time and may not offer the same consistent retention as Kydex. Hybrid holsters combine a leather or neoprene backing for comfort with a Kydex shell for secure retention, offering a great middle ground.
Retention is a non-negotiable safety feature. Passive retention relies on the holster’s inherent tightness, often adjusted via screws, to grip the firearm. Active retention involves a mechanical lock, like a thumb break or hood, that you must disengage to draw the pistol. For everyday carry, a good passive retention system is often sufficient, but for duty or situations where someone might try to grab your gun, an active system is essential.
Finally, do not forget about the belt attachment. A good holster is useless without a good gun belt. Look for sturdy clips, loops, or platforms that securely attach to your belt. Many modern holsters use soft loops or polymer clips that snap over the belt, which work very well. The ability to adjust the cant (the angle of the pistol) and ride height (how high or low the pistol sits) is also a huge plus for finding that perfect, comfortable fit. Taking the time to think through these points will help you find one of the 10 best holster for Glock 17 – range tested options that fits your specific needs.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most comfortable IWB holster position for a Glock 17?
Comfort is subjective and depends a lot on your body type, but the two most common and generally comfortable positions are the appendix carry (around the 12-1 o’clock position) and the strong-side hip (around the 3-4 o’clock for right-handed shooters). Appendix carry keeps the gun centrally located and is often easier to conceal, while strong-side carry avoids having the gun pointed at your femoral artery and can be more comfortable when sitting for long periods. You will need to experiment to see what works best for you.
Can I use a Glock 19 holster for my Glock 17?
Sometimes, but I do not recommend it. While the frames are similar in width, the Glock 17 has a longer slide and barrel. A Glock 19 holster will likely be open at the bottom, which could work, but the muzzle of your G17 will not be fully supported. This can lead to an insecure fit, potential wobble, and even damage to the holster or your pistol over time. It is always best to use a holster specifically molded for your firearm model.
How tight should the retention be on my holster?
The retention should be secure enough that you can turn the holster upside down and shake it vigorously without the gun falling out. However, it should not be so tight that you have to fight or use excessive force to draw the pistol. A good Kydex holster will give a positive “click” when the gun is fully seated. Most holsters with adjustable retention allow you to fine-tune this tension with a simple screwdriver until you find the perfect balance between security and a smooth draw.
Is a weapon light compatible holster necessary?
If you plan on mounting a weapon-mounted light (WML) like a Streamlight TLR-1 or Surefire X300 to your Glock 17, then yes, it is absolutely necessary. A holster must be specifically molded to fit both the pistol and the light. A standard holster will not accommodate the extra bulk, and trying to force it is unsafe and will not work. If a WML is part of your setup, you must filter your search for holsters that are explicitly compatible with your specific light model.
What is the benefit of a holster with an adjustable cant?
An adjustable cant allows you to change the angle at which the pistol rests on your belt. This is a huge benefit for both comfort and concealment. A straight drop (0-degree cant) might work for OWB carry, but for IWB, most people prefer a forward cant (also called the FBI cant). This angles the grip of the pistol closer to your body, which helps conceal it better under a shirt and can also make for a more natural and ergonomic draw stroke.