For the serious bowhunter, reliable penetration is non-negotiable. It’s the difference between a clean, ethical harvest and a difficult recovery. Fixed blade broadheads, with their robust, non-moving parts, are renowned for their strength and consistent performance upon impact, driving deep to create effective wound channels. Choosing the right one for your setup is a critical step in preparing for the season.
This roundup focuses on broadheads built for that singular purpose: dependable deep penetration. We’ve compiled a selection of top-performing fixed blade models from trusted brands and value-packed options. Whether you prioritize ultimate durability, specific cutting diameters, or proven field performance, there’s a broadhead here designed to meet your needs and inspire confidence when you draw back.
Our Picks for the Best Fixed Blade Broadheads
- Dead Ringer Fixed Blade Broadhead | 2 or 3 Blade Designs
- Huntingdoor 12Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads 125 Grain
- Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead – 3 Pack
- Feyachi 100 Grain Stainless Steel Fixed Blade Broadhead, Pack of 6
- OTW Hunting Broadheads, 3 Fixed Blades 100 Grain (6 Pack)
- Muzzy Trocar HB 4 Blade 100gr Hybrid Broadhead
- Vantage Point Archery VPA 1 1/8″ 3 Blade 150 Grain Broadhead
- G5 Montec Fixed Blade Broadhead 3 Pack 125 Grain
- Muzzy One Fixed Blade Broadhead 3 Pack 100 Grain
Dead Ringer Fixed Blade Broadhead
The Dead Ringer Fixed Blade Broadhead offers a choice between two and three-blade designs, allowing you to select the configuration that best suits your hunting style and penetration preferences. This flexibility is a significant advantage for archers who want to fine-tune their setup. The broadheads are built with a focus on strength and reliable flight.
Coming in a convenient pack of three, they provide a solid option for hunters seeking dependable fixed-blade performance. The simple, robust design minimizes potential failure points, contributing to consistent impact performance where it matters most.
Huntingdoor 12Pack 3 Fixed Blade Archery Broadheads 125 Grain
For the hunter who goes through plenty of practice or wants a substantial supply for the season, the Huntingdoor 12-pack presents exceptional value. These 125-grain broadheads feature a heavy-duty three-blade design, engineered for both strength and accuracy. The package includes a full dozen, making them a practical choice for high-volume shooting.
They come with extremely sharp blades right out of the package and use a standard screw-in insert thread. This design ensures easy installation and compatibility with carbon, fiberglass, and aluminum arrows for both compound bows and crossbows, serving as a reliable and accessible option for many shooters.
Muzzy Trocar 100 Grain 3-Blade Broadhead
The Muzzy Trocar is a well-established name in the broadhead market, known for its effective and durable design. This 100-grain, three-blade model features a trocar tip, which is a sharply pointed, three-sided design that initiates penetration with exceptional force. This tip style helps the broadhead push through bone and tough hide efficiently.
As a product made in the United States, it carries a reputation for quality construction. The fixed blade design ensures there are no mechanical parts to fail, providing a straightforward and trustworthy option for hunters who value a proven, traditional broadhead profile with a modern penetrating tip.
Feyachi 100 Grain Stainless Steel Fixed Blade Broadhead
Feyachi’s broadhead is constructed from 420 stainless steel, a material chosen for its maximum durability and resistance to corrosion. The one-piece fixed blade design means the entire head is machined or cast from a single piece of steel, eliminating weak points where blades meet a ferrule. This creates a supremely rugged arrow tip.
This robust construction is made for deep penetration and significant tissue damage. The broadheads can also be resharpened, extending their usable life. With a standard screw-in thread and compatibility across bow types, they offer a strong, no-frills performance package in a convenient six-pack.
OTW Hunting Broadheads, 3 Fixed Blades 100 Grain
The OTW Hunting Broadheads provide a straightforward and effective fixed-blade solution in a generous six-pack. These 100-grain heads are noted as suitable for small game, indicating a design that balances cutting power with practical application for various hunting scenarios. The three fixed blades are designed to open a reliable wound channel.
Their compatibility with both crossbows and compound bows makes them a versatile addition to any archer’s quiver. For hunters looking for an affordable and functional fixed-blade option in a multi-pack, these broadheads present a sensible choice that prioritizes the core fundamentals of penetration and durability.
Muzzy Trocar HB 4 Blade 100gr Hybrid Broadhead
The Muzzy Trocar HB (Hybrid Broadhead) combines a devastating four-blade cutting design with the renowned Trocar tip. This configuration increases the number of cutting edges to four, which can create a larger wound channel and more significant tissue damage upon entry and exit. The hybrid label often refers to its optimized blade angle for strength.
Staying at 100 grains, it maintains common arrow weight compatibility. The fixed, non-mechanical blades ensure power is not lost to deploying mechanisms, translating all the bow’s energy into penetration. This model is for hunters seeking maximum cutting diameter and aggression from a fixed-blade platform.
Vantage Point Archery VPA 1 1/8″ 3 Blade 150 Grain Broadhead
Built for ultimate penetration and cutting power, the VPA broadhead is a heavyweight contender at 150 grains. It is precision machined from 1045 Carbon Tool Steel and hardened to a 50-52 Rockwell rating, which speaks to its exceptional durability and ability to hold a sharp edge even after impacting hard materials. This is a broadhead made to last.
With a 1 1/8-inch cutting diameter and a three-blade design, it is engineered to produce massive wound channels and superior blood trails. Its screw-in design offers universal compatibility, making this rugged, American-made broadhead a top-tier choice for hunters who refuse to compromise on material quality and penetrating force.
G5 Montec Fixed Blade Broadhead 3 Pack 125 Grain
The G5 Montec is a legendary name in fixed-blade broadheads, celebrated for its simple, strong, and accurate one-piece design. Machined from a single block of solid steel, it has no separate blades to bend, break, or loosen. This monolithic construction is the gold standard for durability and reliable in-flight accuracy.
At 125 grains, it offers a middle-weight option that suits a wide range of bow setups. The design is aerodynamic and can be easily resharpened to a razor’s edge for multiple uses. For hunters who want a proven, no-gimmick broadhead that has earned its place through years of field success, the Montec remains a premier selection.
Muzzy One Fixed Blade Broadhead 3 Pack 100 Grain
The Muzzy One broadhead represents a return to a classic, effective fixed-blade formula with modern manufacturing. As a one-piece design, it shares the strength advantages of a monolithic broadhead, ensuring incredible durability and impact resistance. This design philosophy eliminates any concerns about blade alignment or attachment failure.
Weighing 100 grains, it provides a standard weight that works with most arrow spines. The focus is on delivering deep, consistent penetration with a simple and trustworthy cutting structure. It’s an excellent choice for hunters who appreciate the heritage of the Muzzy brand but want the ultimate simplicity and strength of a one-piece construction.
What to Look For in the Best Fixed Broadheads for Reliable Penetration
When I’m picking out my gear for the season, choosing the right fixed-blade broadhead is a decision I take seriously. It’s the business end of your arrow, and its job is to create a massive, bleeding wound channel for a quick, ethical harvest. The goal is reliable penetration, and a few key factors separate the great heads from the mediocre ones. Let’s break down what I always consider.
First up is blade design and steel quality. I look for heads made from high-carbon or stainless steel. This isn’t the place to cheap out. Thicker blades, often .040″ or more, resist bending when they hit bone. The grind is also crucial. A chisel tip is fantastic for punching through shoulder bone, while a cut-on-contact tip slices in with less resistance for deep vital shots. Some of the best fixed broadheads for reliable penetration combine a sharp leading tip with a robust main blade.
Next is the ferrule, the body of the broadhead. I prefer a one-piece or solidly welded design. The more seams and separate parts, the more potential failure points. A streamlined, aerodynamic ferrule helps the head fly true and reduces wind-planing. Weight is part of this equation, too. Heavier arrows with heavier broadheads carry more kinetic energy, which directly translates to deeper penetration. I often see hunters moving to 125-grain or even 150-grain heads for this exact reason.
Finally, think about your setup as a whole. Your broadhead must be compatible with your arrow’s spine and your bow’s tune. A poorly tuned bow will make even the best head fly like a wiffle ball. I always practice extensively with my chosen broadhead before the hunt, making sure my field points and broadheads hit the same point of impact. No single head is perfect for every situation, but by focusing on strong steel, a solid design, and proper tuning, you’ll put yourself in the best position for a clean, pass-through shot.
FAQ
Are fixed-blade broadheads really better for penetration than mechanical ones?
Generally, yes, and here’s why I think so. Fixed-blade heads have no moving parts to deploy, so all the energy from your arrow goes straight into cutting and pushing through tissue and bone. A mechanical head uses some of that energy to open its blades, which can rob a bit of penetration, especially on quartering-away shots or when hitting heavy bone. For maximum reliability, especially on larger game like elk or moose, I trust a well-made fixed blade.
What’s the ideal broadhead weight for deer hunting?
This is a hot topic, but my personal approach is to go heavier than the old 100-grain standard. For whitetails, I often use 125-grain heads. The added weight up front increases my arrow’s front-of-center (FOC), which improves stability and penetration. The key is to ensure your arrow spine is correct for the increased weight. A 125-grain head on a properly spined arrow is a devastating combination for deer-sized game.
How often should I replace my fixed-blade broadheads?
I inspect and often replace blades after every shot, even during practice. A blade that’s hit dirt, rock, or bone will have microscopic rolls or chips in the edge that severely reduce its cutting ability. The ferrule itself can last many seasons if it’s not damaged. I always carry a practice head and a set of fresh hunting heads. Never go into the field with a head you’ve already shot into a target; that’s asking for a poor performance.
Do I need to practice with my broadheads, or are field points enough?
You absolutely must practice with the exact broadheads you plan to hunt with. Even the best fixed-blade head can fly differently than your field points due to wind resistance (planing). I start by tuning my bow at close range with my broadheads, then confirm my accuracy out to my maximum ethical range. This is the only way to guarantee your setup for the best fixed broadheads for reliable penetration is truly dialed in.
What’s more important: a wide cut or deep penetration?
This is a balance, but penetration is the non-negotiable foundation. A head that creates a wide cut but stops short of the vitals is useless. I prioritize designs that are built to drive deep. Once reliable, pass-through penetration is assured, then I look for a respectable cutting diameter—often between 1 and 1.5 inches for fixed blades. Deep penetration ensures a complete pass-through, leaving two holes for blood loss and a better blood trail.